Hello dear
Welcome to The Toast Cafe
At The Toast Cafe, we celebrate the art of homemade breakfast and brunch. Located in the heart of Anderson, Indiana, our charming cafe offers a vibrant 1950s atmosphere that invites you to indulge in delightful culinary experiences. Our menu shines with standout dishes like the melt-in-your-mouth BLT and luscious mushroom gravy, earning rave reviews from our loyal customers. While our passionate staff ensures top-notch service, the warm, welcoming vibe makes every visit memorable. Despite being a newer establishment, The Toast Cafe quickly establishes itself as a local gem, where every meal is crafted with love and a hint of wizardry. Come and savor what our community has to offer!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
The Toast Cafe
Welcome to The Toast Cafe, a delightful culinary haven nestled in the heart of Anderson, Indiana. Located at 28 E 13th St, this charming restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a reputation for homemade comfort foods and exceptional service, this cafe is more than just a place to grab a meal; it's an experience that warms the soul.
Stepping inside, you are greeted by a cozy, 50's-themed decor that emits a nostalgic charm. The ambiance is welcoming, and the staff’s friendly smiles instantly make you feel at home. It's no wonder reviews highlight the cafe as a hidden gem, where the genuine hospitality complements the delicious food.
- Signature Dishes: One standout offering is their mushroom gravy, praised for transforming even the most skeptical diners into believers. As noted by customer Luna0lightning, the service is 'amazing' and the experience memorable—especially if you're a fan of rich, savory sauces.
- Breakfast Heaven: For breakfast lovers, The Toast Cafe shines with its homemade options. As Megan Dunn experienced, even waiting 45 minutes for her meal became worthwhile when she finally indulged in the scrumptious fare. Each dish is crafted with care, and the quality is evident in every bite.
- Classic Comfort: Darren McEntire dubbed his BLT as 'literally god tier,' a testament to the cafe's commitment to quality. The flavors and generous portions leave guests raving about their meals long after the last bite, and the prices remain surprisingly fair.
Customers like Mark B. can’t get enough of the breakfast selections, with many returning for second helpings during their stay in Anderson. Whether you’re after a classic cinnamon roll or a hearty breakfast platter, each dish at The Toast Cafe is designed to be both satisfying and comforting.
If you’re in the area or planning a visit, make sure to add The Toast Cafe to your itinerary. It's not just a meal; it's an experience filled with warmth, flavor, and friendly faces. Prepare to be enchanted by the food and the ambiance, all while enjoying the company of fellow food enthusiasts! Don't miss your chance to indulge in what many guests are calling the best breakfast in town!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Amazing service, great experience, made me love mushroom gravy. 3 Friend comments : Literal wizards, best cinnamon roll ever. “The bread melted in my mouth, how? I don’t know, breads a solid. Wizardry.” ”
“ I had a work trip and wanted breakfast before heading out. I found this place on google, and decided to try it. When we got there it was packed! We had to wait an extra 45 minutes for our food and I didn’t mind at all I didnt realize it’s a new restaurant. They were out of some of the things we ordered and comped our check which they didn’t have to do. But guys THE FOOD IS AMAZING. Everything is homemade. I cannot talk more highly of this place! Loved our server. Loved the food. I have to come back up frequently for work and can’t wait to come back here. ”
“ Picture Waffle House but, like, classy. I had the BLT which is literally god tier. Everyone is so nice and they genuinely want you to enjoy the food and have a good experience. And I can't stress enough it was the BEST BLT I've ever had. Somehow they still manage to have decent fair prices on top of all that. Please expand I want this place to be everywhere I go ”
“ This is a wonderful hidden gem in downtown Anderson, food is Amazing! Portions are more than enough. Service is prompt and friendly, great decor with a 50’s vibe! ”
“ I wish I'd known about this place earlier in our stay in Anderson. I ate there twice the last 2 days we were there. I love breakfast foods, and they're the best in the area, in my opinion. Delicious. ”
“ My family and I had a wonderful experience today. We had been wanting to try the place since it reopened and we are glad we finally did. The service was exceptional, friendly and attentive. The atmosphere was so cute and the food was great from start to finish. The waitress recommended the Gravy Flight as an appetizer and I'm glad she did! All of our meals were also equally good. ”
“ One of the freshest breakfasts I have had. The ingredients were made perfect and there was a consistent bite through the whole dish. The coffee and fresh orange juice is a must try. Great ambiance with 50-60's music to start your day. ”
“ I grew up in Anderson and moved upstate to get t married, when I heard they reopened, I drove an hour and a half for my 40 birthday because all I wanted was the toast! It didn't fail to meet my high expectations. Super friendly staff, amazing food and just tons and tons if memories there! I drink out of my mug I purchased there all the time. Made me cry, I'm extremely thankful and grateful it reopened! It truly is a remarkable restaurant with remarkable people. I cannot say enough nice things to say about this place! The memories, the staff, the food and the atmosphere is second to none! Thank you for being such top notch people! ”